So, you’re staring down summer plans, trying to pick between Lake Michigan and Lake Huron for that perfect getaway. The good news? You can’t go wrong.
The better news? You can go very right, depending on what kind of trip you’re dreaming about.
Living in Michigan, or spending enough time rambling around its coastlines, you get to know the personalities of the lakes pretty intimately.
And while Lake Superior gets all the drama and Lake Erie feels like the scrappy little sibling, Lake Michigan and Lake Huron are the two most summer-ready heavyweights in the Great Lakes lineup.
The Quick Comparison
Before we get into the nitty-gritty, here’s a snapshot to kick things off:
Feature
Lake Michigan
Lake Huron
Beaches
Sandier, wider, often warmer
Quieter, rockier in spots, still beautiful
Town Vibes
Bustling, tourist-friendly (e.g. Traverse City)
Sleepier, more small-town charm (e.g., Rogers City)
Accessibility
Better from Chicago, Milwaukee, and West Michigan
Better from Detroit, Eastern Michigan, Canada
Water Clarity
Pretty good, though it varies
Generally clearer, especially around the Sunrise Coast
Island Options
Fewer, but with gems like South Manitou
More: Mackinac, Drummond, Bois Blanc, etc.
Lighthouses
Dozens, well-maintained, often part of tourist loops
Hundreds, many remote and historic
Crowd Levels
Popular spots get packed
Fewer crowds, even in peak summer
Boating & Fishing
Deep waters, more charter ops
More inlets, reefs, and shallows for casual paddling
Lake Michigan: Big Sand, Big Cities, Big Crowds
Let’s start with the lake that gets the most national attention. Lake Michigan is the only Great Lake fully within the U.S. border, and the whole west coast of Michigan has become kind of a poster child for Midwest summer.
Why People Love It
- The Beaches Are Incredible. From Saugatuck to Sleeping Bear Dunes, it’s long stretches of soft sand and shallow, swimmable water. The sunsets are ridiculous. Like, pull-your-car-over kind of ridiculous.
- The Towns Are Ready for You. You’ve got spots like Grand Haven, with its musical fountain and bustling pier scene, or Petoskey, where you might find one of the famous stones people obsess over. Traverse City? Cherry capital, tons of food, wine tasting, and lake views for days.
- Easy for Chicagoans. If you’re driving from Illinois or Wisconsin, the Lake Michigan coast is a straight shot. No ferries, no border crossings.
But…
If you’re not a fan of packed parking lots, long restaurant waits, or stretching your towel 12 inches from someone else’s cooler, you might want to skip the major tourist zones in late July.
Plus, the water can still be pretty brisk even in the summer, especially further north. Not Superior-cold, but not exactly bathwater either.
Lake Huron: Quieter Shores, Secret Spots, Island Hopping
It’s broader and more complex in shape, wrapping around the thumb of Michigan and stretching all the way north into Canada’s Georgian Bay.
It doesn’t shout for attention, but if you like places with a little mystery and elbow room, it’s a dream.
Where It Wins
- Mackinac Island. Let’s just get that one on the board early. No cars, just bikes, horses, fudge shops, and Gilded Age hotels. It’s busy in summer, yes, but still magical. You can get there from either lake, technically, but it’s a Huron-side jewel.
- So Many Lighthouses. Over 120 just on the U.S. side. And not just well-known ones like Fort Gratiot or Tawas Point. We’re talking rugged, remote ones you might have to hike or paddle to. Great for lighthouse buffs or people who just like something to aim their kayak toward.
- Water Clarity. Especially on the northeast coast near Alpena, Rogers City, or the Les Cheneaux Islands, the water’s like glass. It’s perfect for snorkeling around shipwrecks (yes, actual visible wrecks) or just floating in a cove with a book.
- Underrated Beaches. Tawas Point State Park has some of the softest sand and clearest water in the state. It doesn’t get the PR that Lake Michigan spots do, but that’s kind of the point.
Things to Know
The Huron coast feels more remote, especially as you head north. That’s great if you want solitude, but trickier if you’re expecting lots of bars or shopping.
Cell service can get spotty, and restaurant hours sometimes run on “Up North Time,” especially outside of July and August.
Still, if you like the feeling of discovery of pulling off on a shoulder because you saw something cool and there’s no one around, it’s hard to beat.
Lighthouses: The Tiebreaker?
Here’s where you get into passion territory. Some people plan entire vacations around visiting lighthouses, and honestly, fair.
- Lake Michigan has some iconic ones: Big Sable Point near Ludington, Grand Haven’s red pierhead light (amazing at sunset), and the fairy-tale-like South Haven lighthouse.
- Lake Huron is more spread out and rugged: Forty Mile Point, Middle Island Light (reachable by boat near Alpena), and the remote Pointe aux Barques Light are just a few. Some feel like they’re truly out there, which adds to the magic.
If you’re traveling with kids or you like well-maintained trails and interpretive centers, Lake Michigan lights might be more your speed. But if you’re chasing the kind of photos that feel like you stepped into a history book, go to Huron.
Best Lake for
Let’s break it down even more based on trip style.
Beach Bumming
View this post on Instagram
The dunes, the soft sand, the wide beaches—it’s just built for day-long lounging.
Try Oval Beach in Saugatuck for a postcard-perfect stretch with easy access and a chill vibe, or Warren Dunes near Sawyer if you want to mix your sunbathing with a little dune hiking.
Even farther north, Empire Beach and North Bar Lake near Sleeping Bear Dunes offer some of the best sunset spots in the state.
Kayaking & Paddleboarding
Tons of protected bays, shipwreck sites, and calm mornings make it ideal for a paddle.
The Les Cheneaux Islands near Cedarville offer 36 limestone-fringed islands with quiet channels and clear, shallow waters.
In places like Alpena, you can even kayak right over visible shipwrecks in Thunder Bay National Marine Sanctuary, glass-bottom kayak optional, but amazing either way.
Wining and Dining
@mlivenews The Old Mission Peninsula wine trail in Peninsula Township that extends into Lake Michigan’s Grand Traverse Bay has 10 wineries waiting to be explored #michigan #oldmissionpeninsula #wine #winetrail #thingstodoinmichigan #michigantravel #lovablemichigan #upnorthmichigan #travelmichigan #lakemichigan ♬ Aesthetic – Jimmy Flatting
Traverse City alone has dozens of wineries and tasting rooms, but it doesn’t stop there. The Old Mission and Leelanau Peninsulas have scenic wine trails with lake views around every bend—and some surprisingly good pinot noir and riesling.
Add in local food trucks, lakefront restaurants, and cozy bakeries, and you’ve got a full-blown food getaway.
Camping & Quiet
Negwegon State Park near Alpena is a primitive camping gem, no hookups, no crowds, just trees, beach, and sky.
Rockport State Recreation Area has rugged trails and old quarry ruins to explore, while Port Crescent near the tip of the Thumb offers modern campsites and one of the darkest skies in the Lower Peninsula.
Perfect for late-night stargazing after the campfire dies down.
Romantic Escape
It was a pleasure welcoming the team to Grand Hotel & @mackinacisle! We hope you had a great visit! 🐴 https://t.co/AJYQhkzMWe
— Grand Hotel (@GrandHotelMI) August 3, 2022
Want Victorian luxury and horse-drawn carriages?
Head to the Grand Hotel on Mackinac Island (Huron side), where time slows way down.
Prefer cozy lakefront B&Bs with walkable downtowns and scenic bike trails?
Harbor Springs or Glen Arbor (Michigan side) hit that sweet spot.
Either way, you’re in for peaceful mornings, wine at sunset, and no need to check your email.
Real-World Tips
- Weather Shifts Fast. Both lakes can whip up storms out of nowhere. Always check the forecast before heading out on water, especially in a kayak or small boat.
- Bug Spray = Your Friend. Mosquitoes don’t care if you’re in Michigan or Huron. Bring it, use it.
- If You Only Have a Weekend… Pick the lake that’s closer to where you are. You don’t want to spend half your time in the car.
- Book Early. Even the quieter Huron towns are starting to fill up faster each year. July weekends? Don’t wait.
- Bring Water Shoes. Some beaches on both lakes have rocky patches. It’s not a dealbreaker, but your feet will thank you.
So… Which Is Better?
- If you want action, amenities, and postcard-perfect sunsets, Lake Michigan.
- If you want space, solitude, and a few surprises, Lake Huron.
Some people fall in love with one and stick to it forever. Others bounce between both year to year, depending on what they’re craving.
There’s no wrong choice—just different flavors of right. Either way, you’re spending summer by fresh water that feels like an inland sea, which honestly, is about as good as it gets.